Chapel Hill: Audit finds weak financial controls at UNC's SCiLL
The News & Observer and The Daily Tar Heel each say they obtained a UNC internal-audit report on the School of Civic Life and Leadership. Both describe roughly $5 million in spending and no budget-monitoring process. Scholarship details do not match line for line.
By Alexandru Stanciu · Published

File photo: Mx. Granger (CC0), via Wikimedia Commons.
What we know
Confirmed
- The News & Observer, by Jane Winik Sartwell, was originally published Nov. 18, 2026, at 11:53 a.m., and the page later shows an update at 4:50 p.m. The Daily Tar Heel, by Aidan Lockhart, is dated Nov. 17, 2026. Each paper says it got the UNC Office of Internal Audit report on the School of Civic Life and Leadership through a public-records request. This file does not include the report.Confirmed by The News & Observer, Nov. 18, 2026; The Daily Tar Heel, Nov. 17, 2026
- The Daily Tar Heel says the final report is dated Sept. 8 and that the audit covered Aug. 7, 2025, through April 30, 2026. A deck line on that story says the office reviewed the school from early December 2025 to July 2026. The article body uses those later months for a vacancy, not for the audit window. The News & Observer does not print Aug. 7 or April 30. It places the spending in the first 10 months of fiscal year 2026.Confirmed by The Daily Tar Heel; The News & Observer
- Both papers say the school reported $2.25 million in gifts and $4 million in state funds during the period they describe. The Daily Tar Heel says expenses neared $5 million and that gift money paid for scholarships, catering, retreats, and outings. The News & Observer says the school spent $5 million, listing salaries, speakers, fellowships, scholarships, food, events, travel, supplies, buildings, and technology.Confirmed by The Daily Tar Heel; The News & Observer
- The News & Observer quotes the audit: "SCiLL did not have a deployed budget monitoring process in place during the scope period, likely due to being a developing school and being without a business manager for much of the fiscal year." It also says the audit links the gap to the school being a "newly established School that is in the process of developing sound business practices." The Daily Tar Heel says there was no business manager from early December 2025 until July 2026. The News & Observer says the finance department lacked a manager for five months that the audit covered. SCiLL's reply in the News & Observer says the absence "impeded the normal operation of our budget monitoring systems" and that a new business manager was hired in July 2026.Confirmed by UNC Office of Internal Audit, via The News & Observer; SCiLL management response, via The News & Observer; The Daily Tar Heel
- The News & Observer says the audit did not report fraud or misuse. It describes weak oversight, financial inconsistencies, incomplete travel reporting, and ad-hoc speaker arrangements. The Daily Tar Heel story read here does not use fraud or misuse. It says travel-request forms were regularly completed, as university policy requires, and that one trip's funds included an unused airline ticket that did not appear to have been refunded. Management told that paper the examples involved faculty whose main jobs were in other departments, which still had the lead role in approving those expense reports. On speakers, the campus paper says contractors were engaged before purchasing-contract approval, and that one bill exceeded the approved amount.Confirmed by The News & Observer; The Daily Tar Heel
- The school's Libertas page, read Nov. 18, 2026, offers $3,000 a year, shown as $1,500 a semester, for tuition, fees, and books, renewable up to four years and a $12,000 lifetime maximum when funds and academic performance allow. Students who are minoring, or who intend to minor, may apply. The page says recipients should take at least one or two SCiLL courses a year and should plan to declare the minor during the first year they hold the award.Confirmed by UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership Libertas Scholarships page
- The Daily Tar Heel says the audit found that nine of 63 Libertas recipients took no SCiLL class during the year, that six had not declared the minor by the end of their first year, and that four studied abroad for one semester. The News & Observer says nine recipients of the $1,500-a-semester award for students minoring in the school took no SCiLL class during the year, and that some were studying abroad. It does not print 63, six, or four. SCiLL's reply in the campus paper: "All current Libertas Scholars are meeting the requirements of their scholarships."Confirmed by The Daily Tar Heel, citing the audit and the school's response; The News & Observer
- A UNC spokesperson told The Daily Tar Heel on Oct. 23 that Libertas awards went to 95 undergraduates this fall, that the current group is 142, and that 145 students have held one since the program started. The spokesperson did not name donors. Those three counts are not in the News & Observer story read here. The campus paper says the audit, citing what it calls Tar Heel Reports, found 78 students had declared the minor in spring 2026. The News & Observer says the audit put the spring figure at 78 students pursuing the minor and more than 20 faculty recruited. The school's about page, which is undated on this point, says that in just two years it recruited 20 distinguished faculty.Confirmed by UNC spokesperson, via The Daily Tar Heel; The Daily Tar Heel; The News & Observer; SCiLL about page
- The Civil Discourse Community page says first-year residents receive a $3,000 Civ-Comm fellowship, housing in a residence hall, and an expenses-paid fall retreat. The Daily Tar Heel says all 28 participants were paid the full two-semester $3,000 in the fall, that two did not live in the hall in the spring, and that the lump sum was paid in error. The News & Observer calls the fellowship $1,500 a semester for students living in the hall and says two recipients did not live there all year. It does not print 28, a fall lump sum, or the word error. The campus paper says scholarship and fellowship spending was $282,000 from Aug. 7, 2025, to April 30, 2026. The News & Observer does not print $282,000.Confirmed by SCiLL Civil Discourse Community page; The Daily Tar Heel; The News & Observer
- The school's about page says SCiLL was established in 2023 and names Dean Jed Atkins. On Aug. 11, 2026, the school announced it had become UNC's 15th independent school. The News & Observer also reports that step. The same newspaper says UNC spent $1.2 million this year on an investigation of misconduct allegations at the school and then said the results would stay secret, and that the school got a $5 million infusion from the latest state budget. The article does not say that $5 million repeats each year. The audit's $4 million in state funds is a separate figure, the amount the papers say was reported as received during the review.Confirmed by SCiLL about page; SCiLL announcement, Aug. 11, 2026; The News & Observer
- The News & Observer says Dean Jed Atkins told the UNC System Board of Governors on Wednesday that the school now has 125 minors and 32 faculty, with plans for an undergraduate major and for master's and doctoral programs. Wednesday was Nov. 18, 2026. The Daily Tar Heel story is dated the day before and does not include that briefing. No agenda packet or minutes for the remark were in the documents read here.Confirmed by The News & Observer, Nov. 18, 2026
- The Office of Internal Audit's fiscal year 2026 annual report lists a financial-management review of the School of Civic Life and Leadership with the report date still marked in process. The report says that on June 30, 2026, 18 engagements were finished and three were still underway. That annual report does not contain the scholarship findings, the spending totals, or a Sept. 8 completion date.Confirmed by UNC Office of Internal Audit, Fiscal Year 2026 annual report
Still unknown
- The audit report itself. Both papers say they obtained it. It was not in the documents read here, so conflicts stay with the paper that printed each detail
- Whether the Daily Tar Heel's copy says the audit found no fraud or misuse. Only The News & Observer prints that
- The 63, the six who had not declared, the four who studied abroad, the 28 fellows, the fall lump sum, the word error, and the $282,000 total. Those are the campus paper's account. The News & Observer does not print them
- Minutes or slides for Atkins's Wednesday count of 125 minors and 32 faculty. The number is the News & Observer's account of what he told the board
- The $1.2 million investigation invoice, and the document that keeps the results secret. Both are the News & Observer's account
- Whether the $5 million from the latest state budget is recurring. The News & Observer calls it an infusion and does not say it repeats
- How the about page's undated \"20 distinguished faculty\" relates to the audit's \"more than 20\" or to Wednesday's 32
- Any student's name. None is used
What this means for you
- Schools
- This is not a notice that a student's bill changed, and it is not a finding of fraud by this site. The News & Observer says the audit did not report fraud or misuse. The Daily Tar Heel story read here does not say that. No student is named.
Instructions from UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership pages, read Nov. 18, 2026
Triangle Local is not UNC-Chapel Hill, the Office of Internal Audit, or the UNC System Board of Governors, and it is not an emergency service. Questions about scholarships go to the school. If anyone is in danger, call 911.
What happened
In Chapel Hill, The News & Observer and The Daily Tar Heel both say a UNC internal audit found thin financial controls at the School of Civic Life and Leadership during the opening months of this fiscal year. The school is called SCiLL on campus. Jane Winik Sartwell's story was first published Nov. 18, 2026, at 11:53 a.m., and the page later shows 4:50 p.m. as an update. Aidan Lockhart's campus-paper story is dated Nov. 17. Each newsroom says it received the Office of Internal Audit report through a public-records request. The report is not in this file. No student is named.
Lockhart writes that the final report is dated Sept. 8 and that reviewers looked at Aug. 7, 2025, through April 30, 2026. A line at the top of that story squeezes the work into early December 2025 through July 2026. Lower down, those months are the stretch without a business manager, not the audit's start and stop. This file follows the lower account. Sartwell does not print Aug. 7 or April 30. She puts the spending in the first 10 months of fiscal 2026.
On money in, the papers match. Each says the school reported $2.25 million in gifts and $4 million in state funds. On money out, they are close and not identical. The campus paper says expenses neared $5 million, and that gift funds covered scholarships, catering, retreats, and outings. The News & Observer says the school spent $5 million, and its list runs through salaries, speakers, fellowships, scholarships, food, events, travel, supplies, buildings, and technology. Nearly $5 million and $5 million are left as each paper set them down.
Sartwell quotes the audit directly: "SCiLL did not have a deployed budget monitoring process in place during the scope period, likely due to being a developing school and being without a business manager for much of the fiscal year." She also writes that the audit traces the gap to a "newly established School that is in the process of developing sound business practices." Lockhart says the finance office had no business manager from early December 2025 until July 2026, a majority of the months under review. Sartwell says the department was without a manager for five months the audit actually covered. December through the April 30 stop is about five months. July sits after that stop. A management reply printed by The News & Observer says, "It is correct that the absence of a business manager for most of the fiscal year under review impeded the normal operation of our budget monitoring systems." The next sentence says, "In July 2026, a new business manager was hired, bringing nearly two decades of experience developing and implementing budget monitoring systems in the College of Arts and Sciences."
The News & Observer says the auditors did not report fraud or misuse of funds. What they did report, in that story, was a lack of oversight, inconsistent numbers, incomplete travel reporting, and ad-hoc arrangements for bringing speakers in. Lockhart's story, as read here, never uses fraud or misuse. On travel, he writes that domestic and international request forms were filled out as university policy requires, and that money for one trip included an unused plane ticket that did not look refunded. Management answered, in his account, that the examples were faculty whose primary jobs sat in other departments, and that those departments still held the main duty to approve the reports. On speakers, he writes that the school hired independent contractors for talks without completing a purchasing-contract approval before they spoke, and that one bill ran past the approved sum. That is narrower than Sartwell's "ad-hoc." The two versions are not merged.
The award programs are where the write-ups split. The school's Libertas page, read Nov. 18, offers $3,000 a year, printed as $1,500 a semester, toward tuition, fees, and books. It can renew for up to four years, to a $12,000 lifetime cap, if the money is there and grades hold. Undergraduates who minor in the field, or plan to, may apply. Recipients are told to take at least one or two SCiLL courses a year and to declare the minor in the first year they hold the award. People pictured on that page are not named here.
Lockhart says the audit found nine of 63 Libertas recipients, on a $1,500-a-semester award for students who minor or intend to, took no SCiLL class during the year. He also says six had not declared the minor by the end of that first year, and four spent a semester abroad. Sartwell says nine students getting the $1,500-a-semester award for minors did not enroll in a SCiLL course that year, and that some were abroad. She does not print 63, six, or four. The management line in the campus paper is, "All current Libertas Scholars are meeting the requirements of their scholarships." The audit sentence Lockhart quotes says, "The risk exists that students are receiving SCiLL funding without taking SCiLL courses, declaring the minor, or actively demonstrating progress during the academic year for which the award was paid."
A university spokesperson told The Daily Tar Heel on Oct. 23 that 95 undergraduates received a Libertas award this fall, that the present cohort is 142, and that 145 students have held one since the program began. Donors were not named. Those three figures are not in Sartwell's story. Lockhart adds that the audit, pointing to an internal source it calls Tar Heel Reports, found 78 students had declared the minor in spring 2026. Sartwell's reading of the audit is that, as of this spring, 78 students were pursuing the minor and more than 20 faculty had been recruited. Declared and pursuing are different words, and each stays with the paper that chose it. The school's about page says that in just two years it recruited 20 distinguished faculty. That sentence has no date on the page. It is not Wednesday's number.
Civ-Comm, the Civil Discourse Community, is also told two ways. The school's page says first-year residents get a $3,000 fellowship, a bed in a residence hall, and a fall retreat with expenses paid. Lockhart says the audit looked at a $3,000 award for students in that community, that all 28 of them received the full two-semester amount in the fall, that two were not living in the hall in the spring, and that paying the lump sum was a mistake. Sartwell calls it $1,500 a semester for students who live in the designated hall, and she says two people who were paid did not live there the whole year. She does not print 28, a fall lump sum, or the word error. Two times $1,500 is $3,000, so the sticker amounts can be one award. Only the campus paper calls the fall payment an error. Lockhart also says the audit counted $282,000 in scholarship and fellowship spending from Aug. 7, 2025, to April 30, 2026. Sartwell does not print that sum.
The about page says the school was established in 2023, with Jed Atkins as dean. On Aug. 11, 2026, the school announced it had become Carolina's 15th independent school. The News & Observer reports that change as well. The same story says the university spent $1.2 million this year investigating misconduct allegations inside the school and then said the results would remain secret. That dollar figure and the secrecy line are the newspaper's. They are not in the scholarship passages, and the invoice is not here. Sartwell also writes that the latest state budget sent the school $5 million. She does not say the sum comes back every year, so this file does not call it recurring. The $4 million in state funds above is what both papers say the audit recorded as received during the review. It is not treated as the same appropriation.
Sartwell writes that Atkins told the UNC System Board of Governors on Wednesday the school now has 125 minors and 32 faculty, and that it intends to add an undergraduate major plus master's and doctoral programs. Wednesday was Nov. 18. Lockhart's piece is dated Nov. 17 and does not mention the briefing. The slides and the minutes were not among the records read here.
One official document does name the review and does not contain these findings. The Office of Internal Audit's fiscal 2026 annual report lists "Financial Management - School of Civic Life and Leadership" with the report date still marked in process. The narrative counts the books as of June 30, 2026: 18 engagements done, three still open. There is no Sept. 8 sign-off in that table, and no scholarship list. It shows the office had the school on its plan. It is not a stand-in for the report the two papers requested.
Other UNC finance reporting already on this site includes the out-of-state enrollment penalty and the separate 2027-28 tuition proposal. More from the county is on the Orange County page and in the schools section.
This site is not UNC-Chapel Hill, the Office of Internal Audit, or the Board of Governors, and it is not an emergency service. Scholarship questions go to the school. If anyone is in danger, call 911.
Photos
Text-only. No photograph from The News & Observer, The Daily Tar Heel, or the university pages is used. Students shown or quoted on those university pages are not named.
Why it matters
Chapel Hill's public university had a new school spend about $5 million, by the newspapers' reading of an internal audit, without a working budget check for much of the year. The scholarship gaps are in that same reporting, and the two papers do not list them the same way. The school's public pages still describe the awards one way. The audit, as the campus paper tells it, found cases that did not match.
Updates
Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
First file. Dates, the near-$5 million spending, the $2.25 million in gifts, and the $4 million in state funds are as the two papers describe the audit. The Sept. 8 date and the Aug. 7-to-April 30 window are The Daily Tar Heel. No fraud or misuse is The News & Observer only. Scholarship counts that appear in only one paper stay with that paper. The annual report still listed the review as in process on June 30, 2026, and is not the findings document. lead is false. onTikTok is false. Text-only. No student is named.
Sources
- How UNC's School of Civic Life spent $5M in 10 months with little oversight (The News & Observer, Jane Winik Sartwell. Originally published November 18, 2026, 11:53 a.m. Page shows Updated November 18, 2026, 4:50 p.m.). Public-records copy of the audit. First 10 months of fiscal 2026. Spent $5 million. No deployed budget-monitoring process. The audit quotation and the newly-established-school quotation used here. Five months without a manager inside the audit window. Management reply on the vacancy and the July 2026 hire. No fraud or misuse reported. Incomplete travel reporting and ad-hoc speaker processes, in the paper's words. Nine Libertas recipients with no SCiLL class, some studying abroad. $1,500 a semester. Civ-Comm at $1,500 a semester, two recipients not in the hall all year. Gifts of $2.25 million and $4 million in state funds. Spring count of 78 students pursuing the minor and more than 20 faculty, from the audit. Wednesday Board of Governors briefing by Dean Jed Atkins, 125 minors and 32 faculty. Founded 2023. $1.2 million misconduct investigation whose results the university would keep secret. $5 million from the latest state budget, not described as recurring. Fifteenth independent unit. Text-only. No News & Observer photo is used. No student is named.
Third-party sourcePublished by The News & Observer · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- Audit of School of Civic Life and Leadership reveals financial errors, $2.25 million in donations (The Daily Tar Heel, Aidan Lockhart, Nov. 17, 2026). Public-records copy. Final report dated Sept. 8. Audit window Aug. 7, 2025, to April 30, 2026. The deck's December-to-July line is the vacancy in the body, not the window used here. No business manager from early December 2025 until July 2026. Expenses neared $5 million. Gifts $2.25 million. State funds $4 million. Nine of 63 Libertas recipients took no SCiLL class. Six had not declared by the end of the first year. Four studied abroad for one semester. Management line that all current Libertas Scholars are meeting requirements. Spokesperson statement of Oct. 23: 95 awards this fall, cohort of 142, 145 since the program began. Spring 2026 declaration count of 78, via Tar Heel Reports. Civ-Comm: all 28 paid $3,000 in the fall, two not in the hall in the spring, lump sum in error. $282,000 on scholarships and fellowships. Travel forms regularly completed. One unused ticket apparently not refunded. Contractors engaged before purchasing approval, one bill over the contract. The risk sentence quoted here. The story does not say the audit found no fraud. Text-only. No Daily Tar Heel image is used. No student is named.
Third-party sourcePublished by The Daily Tar Heel · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- Libertas Scholarships (UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership page, read Nov. 18, 2026). $3,000 a year, shown as $1,500 a semester, for tuition, fees, and books. Renewable up to four years, $12,000 lifetime maximum, if funds and academic performance allow. Open to undergraduates minoring or intending to minor. Recipients should take at least one or two SCiLL courses a year and should plan to declare the minor in the first year they hold the award. Profile names on the page are not used.
Official sourcePublished by UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- Civil Discourse Community (UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership page, read Nov. 18, 2026). Partnership with Carolina Housing. First-year residents are offered a $3,000 Civ-Comm fellowship, a residence-hall place, and an expenses-paid fall retreat. The page does not say the money is paid as a fall lump sum, and it does not say a spring move-out claws it back. Resident quotations on the page are not used. No student is named.
Official sourcePublished by UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- About the School of Civic Life and Leadership (page read Nov. 18, 2026). Established in 2023. Dean Jed Atkins is named. The page says that in just two years the school recruited 20 distinguished faculty and taught over 1,300 students. That faculty sentence has no date. It is not used as Wednesday's count. No student is named.
Official sourcePublished by UNC School of Civic Life and Leadership · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- SCiLL is Now UNC's 15th Independent School (school announcement, Aug. 11, 2026, read Nov. 18, 2026). The university said that day that the school had become an independent academic unit, its 15th independent school. A student comment on the page is not used. No student is named.
Official sourcePublished by UNC-Chapel Hill · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
- Fiscal Year 2026 Annual Report of the Activities of the Office of Internal Audit (UNC-Chapel Hill, work-plan table read Nov. 18, 2026). Lists Financial Management - School of Civic Life and Leadership with the report date in process. Narrative says that on June 30, 2026, 18 of the planned engagements were complete and three were still underway. The table does not give scholarship findings, a $5 million total, or a Sept. 8 report date. Used only to show the review was on the office's plan. Text-only.
Official sourcePublished by UNC Office of Internal Audit · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 8:15 PM
More from Orange County
Orange County newsRelated stories
File photo
Cary: Wake school board approves 2027-28 reassignment plan
The News & Observer and ABC11 report an 8-1 vote Tuesday in Cary. The newspaper says the plan moves 1,582 students, largely to fill the new Morrisville High. Families can check a 2027-28 assignment on the district site.
File photo
Raleigh: Wake school board rejects cell tower at Brassfield Elementary
Two news accounts say the board turned down a 185-foot tower lease Tuesday night. The News & Observer reported a 6-3 vote. WRAL reported that three of nine members voted to approve.
File photo
Raleigh: Saint Augustine's University puts a restructuring officer in charge
The university said Nov. 13 that Judge David Warren approved Malcomb Coley as chief restructuring officer at a Nov. 10 hearing. The board had asked for that appointment on Nov. 7. This file is published Nov. 16. It does not backdate the hearing.

.jpg?width=800)