Raleigh: Wake school board rejects cell tower at Brassfield Elementary
Two news accounts say the board turned down a 185-foot tower lease Tuesday night. The News & Observer reported a 6-3 vote. WRAL reported that three of nine members voted to approve.
By Alexandru Stanciu · Published
.jpg?width=1200)
File photo: James Willamor (CC BY-SA 3.0), via Wikimedia Commons.
What we know
Confirmed
- The Wake County Public School System school board page lists a Board of Education meeting on Nov. 17, 2026, from 5:30 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. at Crossroads I, Board Room. The district's school list names Brassfield and links to brassfieldes.wcpss.net. The page does not state a cell-tower vote.Confirmed by Wake County Public School System school board page, checked Nov. 18, 2026
- NC govwatch, a third-party listing of district agenda titles, includes an item called OPTION AND GROUND LEASE - WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY (BRASSFIELD ELEMENTARY) on the Nov. 17, 2026, 5:30 p.m. board agenda. The listing is a title. It does not report a vote.Confirmed by NC govwatch agenda listing, checked Nov. 18, 2026
- The News & Observer reported that the Wake County school board voted 6-3 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, to reject a lease for a 185-foot cell tower at Brassfield Elementary School in Raleigh. It named Chris Heagarty, Cheryl Caulfield, Lynn Edmonds, Christina Gordon, Jennifer Job and Wing Ng as voting against, and vice chair Sam Hershey, Toshiba Rice and chair Tyler Swanson as voting for.Confirmed by The News & Observer, updated Nov. 17, 2026
- WRAL's story, updated Wednesday morning, says the board Tuesday night rejected a 185-foot cell tower next to a North Raleigh elementary school. It says just three of the nine members voted to approve the lease with APC-EDGE. It calls the campus Brassfield Road Elementary. It does not print a 6-3 line and does not name the three yes votes.Confirmed by WRAL, updated Nov. 18, 2026
- Both outlets describe the rejected proposal as 185 feet tall, with $30,000 due in the first year, after neighbors and the school's PTA opposed it. The News & Observer says the board tabled the lease on Oct. 20. WRAL says the board delayed an October vote. The News & Observer says the tower would have stood 96 feet from the track and that APC had lowered it by 10 feet and moved it 20 feet farther from the track and the building. WRAL says the height was lowered from 199 feet to 185 and that the tower was moved 20 feet farther west.Confirmed by The News & Observer, updated Nov. 17, 2026; WRAL, updated Nov. 18, 2026
- The News & Observer says Wake would have been paid $30,000 a year at the start, that the tower was to be built for Verizon, and that APC EDGE said the district could have earned $1.5 million over 25 years depending on how many other providers used it. WRAL says the rejected lease paid $30,000 in the first year, rising 3 percent a year, for an initial 10 years with options out to 25 years, and that the agreement could generate an estimated $1.5 million over the full term.Confirmed by The News & Observer, updated Nov. 17, 2026; WRAL, updated Nov. 18, 2026
- The News & Observer quotes board member Chris Heagarty: he said he thinks the tower is safe, and asked whether damage to the school and the community is offset by $15,000 or $30,000. WRAL prints a shorter version of that remark and does not say how he voted. WRAL quotes board member Jennifer Job, before her no vote, saying that if the district had the funding it needed this would not even be a discussion, probably. The News & Observer quotes Job saying that if the district had the funding it needed, this would not even be a discussion, and that her no vote does not mean she will oppose cell towers in the future.Confirmed by The News & Observer, updated Nov. 17, 2026; WRAL, updated Nov. 18, 2026
Still unknown
- The district's own minutes or roll call. The Simbli meeting page returned an Incapsula block and no readable text on Nov. 18, 2026
- The tally. The News & Observer reports 6-3 and names nine votes. WRAL reports that three of nine voted to approve and does not say the other six all voted no. A Govly summary of the same meeting says the vote was 8-1. This file does not use 8-1.
- The earlier height. The News & Observer says the tower was cut by 10 feet. WRAL says it went from 199 feet to 185. Both call the proposal the board rejected 185 feet.
- How the $1.5 million figure was calculated. The newspaper attributes a potential total to APC and to other carriers. WRAL calls it an estimate over the full term of the rejected lease
What this means for you
- Schools
- The News & Observer and WRAL both report that the cell-tower lease at Brassfield Elementary was rejected. No tower from that lease is approved in those accounts.
Instructions from Wake County Public School System
This site is not the Wake County Public School System or the Board of Education. For board materials, use the district's board pages on wcpss.net. This site is not an emergency service. If anyone is in danger, call 911.
What happened
In Raleigh, the Wake County school board rejected a lease that would have put a 185-foot cell tower on the Brassfield Elementary campus, The News & Observer and WRAL report.
The district's school board page lists a Board of Education meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, from 5:30 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. at Crossroads I. Its school list calls the campus Brassfield. Neither line on that page states the outcome of a tower vote. NC govwatch, which reprints district agenda titles, lists an item named "OPTION AND GROUND LEASE - WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY (BRASSFIELD ELEMENTARY)" for that meeting. The title is all that listing shows.
The district's Simbli page for the meeting returned no readable agenda or minutes on Wednesday morning. An Incapsula block came back instead. The result below is not from that page.
What the two news accounts say
The News & Observer, updated Tuesday night, says the board voted 6-3 to reject the lease. It says Chris Heagarty, Cheryl Caulfield, Lynn Edmonds, Christina Gordon, Jennifer Job and Wing Ng voted no. It says vice chair Sam Hershey, Toshiba Rice and chair Tyler Swanson voted yes.
WRAL's story now says the board rejected the tower on Tuesday night. The page's machine-readable update time is 5:40 a.m. Eastern on Nov. 18. WRAL says three of the nine members voted to approve the lease with APC-EDGE. It does not print "6-3," and it does not name the three yes votes. It calls the school Brassfield Road Elementary. The newspaper says Brassfield Elementary.
A Govly summary of the same meeting says the rejection was 8-1. That figure is not in either news story, and it is not a district roll call. The tally below leaves it out.
Both outlets agree on the height the board turned down: 185 feet. Both say neighbors had fought the plan, and both say the PTA is against it. The newspaper says the board tabled the lease on Oct. 20. WRAL says an October vote was delayed after neighbors asked for more review.
Money, site and the earlier height
The News & Observer says Wake would have received $30,000 a year at the start, for a tower built for Verizon. It says APC EDGE told the district the site could have brought in $1.5 million over 25 years, depending on how many other carriers wanted space. WRAL describes the rejected lease as $30,000 in year one, then a 3 percent annual increase, with a 10-year initial term and options out to 25 years. WRAL says that agreement could have generated an estimated $1.5 million over the full term. Those are not the same explanation of the $1.5 million, so this file keeps them separate.
On the site work, the newspaper says APC had cut the height by 10 feet and moved the tower 20 feet farther from the track and the building, and that it would have stood 96 feet from the track. WRAL says the group lowered the proposal from 199 feet to 185 and moved it 20 feet farther west, and that it could not move farther without disturbing a stormwater pond. The 10-foot cut and the 199-foot starting height do not describe the same change. Both still call the rejected tower 185 feet. Neither earlier height is adopted here.
What board members said
The newspaper quotes Heagarty saying he thinks the tower is safe, then asking whether harm to the campus and the neighborhood is really offset by $15,000 or $30,000. WRAL shortens that remark to the safety line and the question of whether it is worth it.
WRAL quotes Job, before her vote against the lease, that a better-funded district would not be having the discussion at all, and it includes the word "probably." The News & Observer's version of that sentence has no "probably," and it adds that her no vote does not mean she will oppose cell towers later.
The newspaper also quotes PTA president Ellen Gowdy, who said the yearly payment would not make a dent in the district's budget deficit and that one lawsuit could cost more than the tower would ever bring in. WRAL quotes the PTA's stated reasons as the location, the proximity to student activity areas, campus impacts, and the lack of a benefit to the school that matches those impacts. WRAL also quotes parent Mark Chen: "Families with the means to choose another school will now have a 185-foot reason to do so."
Parents and the company also disagreed, in both stories, about radio-frequency health research. This file does not judge that research. It only records that opponents raised it and that the company told the board the tower was safe.
Families can follow board materials on wcpss.net. See Wake schools coverage, the Raleigh page and Wake County news.
This site is not the school district. If anyone is in danger, call 911.
Related coverage
Photos
Text-only. No News & Observer, WRAL or district photographs are used here.
Why it matters
The board declined a lease that would have put a 185-foot tower on an elementary campus in Raleigh after neighbors and the PTA objected.
Updates
Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
First file from the district school board page, the NC govwatch agenda title, The News & Observer and the updated WRAL story. The 6-3 split is the newspaper's account. WRAL says three of nine voted to approve. A Govly 8-1 summary is not used. Simbli returned no readable text. No outlet or district photos. lead is false. onTikTok is false.
Sources
- School Board (WCPSS page: Board of Education meeting listed Nov. 17, 2026, 5:30 p.m. to 10:00 p.m., Crossroads I, Board Room; school directory lists Brassfield at brassfieldes.wcpss.net. The page does not report a tower vote. Text-only. No district photos used.)
Official sourcePublished by Wake County Public School System · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
- Wake County Board of Education meeting page, Nov. 17, 2026 (Simbli). A Nov. 18, 2026 check returned an Incapsula block and no agenda or minutes text, so this file does not use Simbli for the vote.
Official sourcePublished by Wake County Public School System · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
- Board of Education Meeting, Nov. 17, 2026, 5:30 p.m. (NC govwatch listing of WCPSS agenda titles: OPTION AND GROUND LEASE - WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY (BRASSFIELD ELEMENTARY). Title only. No vote. Third-party summary, not a district minutes page.)
Third-party sourcePublished by NC govwatch · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
- Wake school board rejects cell tower at Brassfield Elementary (The News & Observer / T. Keung Hui, updated Nov. 17, 2026, 10:59 p.m.; first published 10:29 p.m.: 6-3 Tuesday vote against a 185-foot tower lease at Brassfield Elementary in Raleigh; no votes from Heagarty, Caulfield, Edmonds, Gordon, Job and Ng; yes votes from Hershey, Rice and Swanson; $30,000 a year at the start for a Verizon tower; APC EDGE figure of $1.5 million over 25 years depending on other providers; tabled Oct. 20; height cut by 10 feet; moved 20 feet; 96 feet from the track. Text-only. No News & Observer or district photos used.)
Third-party sourcePublished by The News & Observer · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
- Wake rejects cell tower next to Raleigh elementary school (WRAL / Emily Walkenhorst. Page dateModified 2026-11-18T10:40:54Z; visible stamp Updated 11/18/2026, 10:40:54 AM; first posted 11/17/2026, 9:00:00 AM. The updated story says the board Tuesday night rejected a 185-foot tower; three of nine members voted to approve the APC-EDGE lease; Brassfield Road Elementary PTA opposed it; $30,000 in year one, then 3 percent a year; initial term 10 years with options to 25; estimated $1.5 million over the full term; height lowered from 199 to 185; moved 20 feet west. Text-only. No WRAL photos used.)
Third-party sourcePublished by WRAL · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
- 2026-11-17 Board Meeting (Govly public summary: says the board rejected the Brassfield Elementary cell-tower lease with APC Edge by an 8-1 vote. That tally is not used. The summary is not district minutes.)
Third-party sourcePublished by Govly · Checked Nov 18, 2026, 6:28 AM
More from Wake County
Wake County newsRelated stories
File photo
Chapel Hill: Audit finds weak financial controls at UNC's SCiLL
The News & Observer and The Daily Tar Heel each say they obtained a UNC internal-audit report on the School of Civic Life and Leadership. Both describe roughly $5 million in spending and no budget-monitoring process. Scholarship details do not match line for line.
File photo
Cary: Wake school board approves 2027-28 reassignment plan
The News & Observer and ABC11 report an 8-1 vote Tuesday in Cary. The newspaper says the plan moves 1,582 students, largely to fill the new Morrisville High. Families can check a 2027-28 assignment on the district site.
File photo
Chapel Hill: UNC faces about $4.9 million over out-of-state cap
A UNC System enrollment report lists Chapel Hill 104 first-year students over its 18 percent nonresident cap, a second straight year. The News & Observer reported Monday that the state budget reduction is $4.9 million. The report does not print a dollar total.

